top of page

Chatgpt resist to fasting?

  • Writer: davidsmith208
    davidsmith208
  • May 20
  • 3 min read

“Fifty times” is probably too high if you mean explicit advocacy of fasting or stomach-emptiness as a spiritual discipline in the Masnavi. But if you include allusions to:

  • eating little,

  • hunger,

  • restraint,

  • the dangers of gluttony,

  • emptiness as receptivity,

  • reduction of bodily domination,

  • Ramadan symbolism,

  • and “feeding on divine food,”

then the total number of relevant passages could indeed become quite large — perhaps several dozen across the six books.

The page you showed reflects a very real and recurring theme in Rumi.


What Rumi actually emphasizes

Rumi repeatedly associates:

  • overeating,

  • heaviness,

  • bodily domination,

  • sleepiness,

  • dullness of perception,

with spiritual obstruction.

And he associates:

  • hunger,

  • lightness,

  • emptiness,

  • fasting,

  • patience,

  • wakefulness,

with receptivity to divine perception.

The core symbolic pattern is:

Bodily fullness

Spiritual consequence

heaviness

forgetfulness

satiety

dullness

excess sleep

heedlessness

egoic appetite

spiritual blindness

versus:

Hunger/emptiness

Spiritual consequence

fasting

subtle perception

emptiness

receptivity

restraint

wakefulness

patience

divine nourishment


The exact passage you cited

The verses around Book V 1743–1749 are part of a recognizable Rumi theme:

earthly food fills the stomach


but blocks subtler nourishment.

The metaphor of the crow is classic:

  • the greedy crow = lower appetite mind.

Rumi often says:

  • bodily reduction opens spiritual perception.

Not necessarily starvation —


but lightness.


How often does this appear?

A rough estimate:

Type of reference

Approximate frequency

Explicit fasting praise

15–25

Hunger as spiritual metaphor

40–80

Critiques of overeating/gluttony

20–40

Emptying for divine reception

pervasive

So your intuition is directionally correct if you mean the broader motif rather than explicit legal fasting instructions.


Important nuance: Rumi is usually symbolic

Rumi is not mainly a dietary ascetic writer in the harsh monastic sense.

He generally avoids:

  • extreme bodily hatred,

  • severe self-punishment,

  • purely legalistic fasting.

Instead he uses hunger symbolically:

Hunger means:

  • receptivity,

  • longing,

  • incompleteness before God,

  • interior openness.

For Rumi:

spiritual growth requires becoming unfilled by the ego.


“Divine food” in Rumi

A recurring idea is that:

  • humans can feed on subtler realities.

This includes:

  • love,

  • remembrance,

  • contemplation,

  • beauty,

  • music,

  • spiritual states,

  • divine presence.

He often contrasts:

  • “animal food”


    with

  • “food of the spirit.”

This comes partly from:

  • Quranic imagery,

  • Sufi metaphysics,

  • Neoplatonic psychology.


Burhaneddin and Shams

The author on your page is probably referring to:

  • Burhan al-Din Muhaqqiq Tirmidhi

  • Shams-i Tabrizi

Traditional Sufi biographies often portray advanced mystics as:

  • eating little,

  • sleeping little,

  • remaining inwardly absorbed.

But historically, hagiographies tend to amplify ascetic traits.


A deeper Sufi principle behind this

In many Sufi traditions there is a fourfold reduction discipline:

  1. eat less

  2. sleep less

  3. speak less

  4. socialize less

because excess sensory engagement was believed to:

  • thicken consciousness,

  • strengthen nafs (ego-self),

  • reduce subtle awareness.

This is widespread beyond Rumi:

  • early Sufis,

  • Christian desert monks,

  • Hesychasts,

  • yogic traditions,

  • Buddhist monastics.


But Rumi also warns against egoic asceticism

This is crucial.

Rumi repeatedly criticizes:

  • prideful fasting,

  • performative holiness,

  • harsh self-denial done for status.

He does not teach:

starvation automatically produces enlightenment.

Rather:

emptiness must become receptivity to divine presence.

Without love and transformation, asceticism becomes another ego identity.


Physiological dimension

Interestingly, modern neuroscience partially aligns with some ancient observations:

Moderate fasting can temporarily:

  • sharpen alertness,

  • increase catecholamines,

  • alter perception,

  • heighten attentional clarity.

But prolonged or excessive fasting can also:

  • impair cognition,

  • dysregulate hormones,

  • destabilize mood.

So traditions usually aimed at:

  • disciplined moderation,


    not collapse.

Rumi’s imagery generally points toward:

  • lightness,

  • wakefulness,

  • inward sensitivity,

rather than self-destruction.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Don Miller Park and Haunted Hydro kayak

Since you’re looking at the Don Miller Park / Haunted Hydro area, there’s a useful clue from the whitewater community: the section from the former Ballville Dam site down toward Don Miller Park is gen

 
 
 
Solzhenitsyn’s Tennis

Yes, Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn spent nearly 18 years living in the small town of Cavendish, from 1976 until his return to Russia in 1994. He chose the area because its forests, hills, and rural character

 
 
 
In heaven we shall play tennis

Yes, surprisingly, Vladimir Nabokov was a serious tennis enthusiast. He was not a professional player, but tennis appears throughout his life and fiction. He played regularly, especially in Europe and

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by Nick Martinez. Proudly created with Wix.com

© Copyright
bottom of page