top of page

Chatgpt resist to fasting?

  • Writer: davidsmith208
    davidsmith208
  • May 20
  • 3 min read

“Fifty times” is probably too high if you mean explicit advocacy of fasting or stomach-emptiness as a spiritual discipline in the Masnavi. But if you include allusions to:

  • eating little,

  • hunger,

  • restraint,

  • the dangers of gluttony,

  • emptiness as receptivity,

  • reduction of bodily domination,

  • Ramadan symbolism,

  • and “feeding on divine food,”

then the total number of relevant passages could indeed become quite large — perhaps several dozen across the six books.

The page you showed reflects a very real and recurring theme in Rumi.


What Rumi actually emphasizes

Rumi repeatedly associates:

  • overeating,

  • heaviness,

  • bodily domination,

  • sleepiness,

  • dullness of perception,

with spiritual obstruction.

And he associates:

  • hunger,

  • lightness,

  • emptiness,

  • fasting,

  • patience,

  • wakefulness,

with receptivity to divine perception.

The core symbolic pattern is:

Bodily fullness

Spiritual consequence

heaviness

forgetfulness

satiety

dullness

excess sleep

heedlessness

egoic appetite

spiritual blindness

versus:

Hunger/emptiness

Spiritual consequence

fasting

subtle perception

emptiness

receptivity

restraint

wakefulness

patience

divine nourishment


The exact passage you cited

The verses around Book V 1743–1749 are part of a recognizable Rumi theme:

earthly food fills the stomach


but blocks subtler nourishment.

The metaphor of the crow is classic:

  • the greedy crow = lower appetite mind.

Rumi often says:

  • bodily reduction opens spiritual perception.

Not necessarily starvation —


but lightness.


How often does this appear?

A rough estimate:

Type of reference

Approximate frequency

Explicit fasting praise

15–25

Hunger as spiritual metaphor

40–80

Critiques of overeating/gluttony

20–40

Emptying for divine reception

pervasive

So your intuition is directionally correct if you mean the broader motif rather than explicit legal fasting instructions.


Important nuance: Rumi is usually symbolic

Rumi is not mainly a dietary ascetic writer in the harsh monastic sense.

He generally avoids:

  • extreme bodily hatred,

  • severe self-punishment,

  • purely legalistic fasting.

Instead he uses hunger symbolically:

Hunger means:

  • receptivity,

  • longing,

  • incompleteness before God,

  • interior openness.

For Rumi:

spiritual growth requires becoming unfilled by the ego.


“Divine food” in Rumi

A recurring idea is that:

  • humans can feed on subtler realities.

This includes:

  • love,

  • remembrance,

  • contemplation,

  • beauty,

  • music,

  • spiritual states,

  • divine presence.

He often contrasts:

  • “animal food”


    with

  • “food of the spirit.”

This comes partly from:

  • Quranic imagery,

  • Sufi metaphysics,

  • Neoplatonic psychology.


Burhaneddin and Shams

The author on your page is probably referring to:

  • Burhan al-Din Muhaqqiq Tirmidhi

  • Shams-i Tabrizi

Traditional Sufi biographies often portray advanced mystics as:

  • eating little,

  • sleeping little,

  • remaining inwardly absorbed.

But historically, hagiographies tend to amplify ascetic traits.


A deeper Sufi principle behind this

In many Sufi traditions there is a fourfold reduction discipline:

  1. eat less

  2. sleep less

  3. speak less

  4. socialize less

because excess sensory engagement was believed to:

  • thicken consciousness,

  • strengthen nafs (ego-self),

  • reduce subtle awareness.

This is widespread beyond Rumi:

  • early Sufis,

  • Christian desert monks,

  • Hesychasts,

  • yogic traditions,

  • Buddhist monastics.


But Rumi also warns against egoic asceticism

This is crucial.

Rumi repeatedly criticizes:

  • prideful fasting,

  • performative holiness,

  • harsh self-denial done for status.

He does not teach:

starvation automatically produces enlightenment.

Rather:

emptiness must become receptivity to divine presence.

Without love and transformation, asceticism becomes another ego identity.


Physiological dimension

Interestingly, modern neuroscience partially aligns with some ancient observations:

Moderate fasting can temporarily:

  • sharpen alertness,

  • increase catecholamines,

  • alter perception,

  • heighten attentional clarity.

But prolonged or excessive fasting can also:

  • impair cognition,

  • dysregulate hormones,

  • destabilize mood.

So traditions usually aimed at:

  • disciplined moderation,


    not collapse.

Rumi’s imagery generally points toward:

  • lightness,

  • wakefulness,

  • inward sensitivity,

rather than self-destruction.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Less Need

There is less need for coloration and decoration - you just go to the place and expunge the ego. The place in the morning is where the bird sings. Total detachment leads to less gravity. When you l

 
 
 
Davis Besse

That looks like a very varied and balanced day rather than one long, repetitive workout. You combined: 2-mile walk with your wife at 6 a.m. — social and emotional connection plus light aerobic exercis

 
 
 
Active recovery

That pattern is interesting because it matches what exercise physiology would predict. You had: Friday: tennis + pickleball accumulation Saturday morning: 3 tennis sets Then beach volleyball Then outd

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by Nick Martinez. Proudly created with Wix.com

© Copyright
bottom of page