top of page

Everett Emerson and Homer

Writer: davidsmith208
davidsmith208
Nov 10
5 min read

Yes. You’ve picked up on an important connection in Richard Richardson’s Emerson: The Mind on Fire. Edward Everett was not simply another Harvard professor. He was one of the formative intellectual influences on the young Emerson, and he helped introduce him to a radically more modern way of reading ancient literature.

The Homer question is particularly interesting because it touches on something much larger: the transition from accepting ancient texts as authoritative works by a single inspired genius to examining how literature actually develops over centuries.

1. Who was Edward Everett (1794–1865)?

Edward Everett

  • Born in 1794 in Dorchester, Massachusetts.

  • Harvard graduate and exceptionally gifted classical scholar.

  • Studied in Europe, particularly at the University of Göttingen.

  • Became Harvard’s first professor of Greek literature in 1819.

  • Later became a congressman, governor of Massachusetts, U.S. senator, diplomat and Secretary of State.

Everett was something of a phenomenon. He was only 25 when he returned from Germany to Harvard.

What made him so influential was that he represented a new kind of American intellectual. He had experienced European scholarship firsthand, spoke several languages, and brought the latest German approaches to classical literature into an American university.

For Emerson, he embodied the possibility that scholarship could be intellectually exciting, aesthetically beautiful and personally transformative.

Everett eventually became famous as an orator. Interestingly, he was the featured speaker at Gettysburg in November 1863, immediately before Lincoln delivered the Gettysburg Address.

2. What exactly was Wolf’s theory of Homer?

Friedrich August Wolf (1759–1824)

German classical scholar whose 1795 book Prolegomena ad Homerum transformed the study of Homer.

Before Wolf, the conventional understanding was straightforward:

  • Homer was a historical Greek poet.

  • He composed the Iliad and the Odyssey.

  • The poems were transmitted substantially as he created them.

Wolf challenged the historical assumptions behind that picture.

His argument was roughly this:

  • The poems originated in an age when writing was not sufficiently developed to preserve such enormous compositions.

  • They therefore circulated orally, through generations of poets and performers.

  • Different sections and episodes had independent histories.

  • Eventually, these materials were collected, organized and edited into the two great epics we possess.

Wolf’s argument was revolutionary because it suggested that the Homeric poems might not be the creations of one individual in the familiar literary sense.

He wasn’t merely questioning Homer’s identity. He was questioning the very idea of how ancient literature came into existence.

This is what made his work so disturbing and exciting to scholars like Everett and, indirectly, Emerson.

The University of Chicago’s history of Homeric scholarship provides an excellent account of Wolf’s argument and the subsequent debate. The University of Chicago Library +1

3. Has Wolf’s theory been proven?

Partly, and in some respects the subsequent scholarship went much further than Wolf himself.

The most important development came in the twentieth century through two scholars:

Milman Parry (1902–1935)

Demonstrated the importance of oral-formulaic composition in Homeric poetry.

Albert Lord (1912–1991)

Extended Parry’s research and showed how oral epic poets could create enormous, sophisticated narratives without memorizing a fixed written text.

Parry and Lord studied living oral poets in Yugoslavia, particularly singers who performed lengthy epic poetry without relying on written manuscripts.

They discovered something remarkable.

These performers used:

  • Repeated phrases and expressions.

  • Standardized descriptions of characters and actions.

  • Recurring poetic structures.

  • Familiar episodes that could be recombined.

  • Traditional rhythmic and metrical patterns.

For example, Homer’s recurring descriptions of particular heroes and gods were not necessarily signs of careless repetition. They were part of a sophisticated oral compositional system.

A poet could construct an enormous narrative during performance using a traditional vocabulary of formulas and patterns.

This gave scholars a much better explanation for the repetitions and variations in Homer.

It also established that oral composition could produce extraordinarily complex literature.

The oral-formulaic approach is now foundational in Homeric scholarship. Springer +1

4. So was there one Homer or many?

This is where things get especially interesting. There are three different questions that are sometimes confused.

Question

What scholarship suggests

Were there many poets in the oral tradition?

Almost certainly yes.

Did many poets contribute material over generations?

Almost certainly, in the development of the tradition.

Were the actual Iliad and Odyssey assembled by numerous poets?

Unsettled; many scholars favor substantial shaping by individual master composers.

My interpretation of the current evidence would be as follows.

The Iliad

It is a remarkably unified work. Its narrative revolves around Achilles’ anger and its consequences. The events, characters and emotional development have a powerful overall coherence.

It is quite plausible that a single exceptionally gifted oral poet gave the Iliad its essential shape, drawing on centuries of inherited material.

The Odyssey

It is also a highly unified work, but its structure is different. It has multiple narrative strands, including Odysseus’s travels, his return to Ithaca, and the events surrounding his wife Penelope and son Telemachus.

It may have been composed by a different poet from the Iliad’s composer. Whether the two works ultimately came from the same individual remains debated.

One useful distinction: the existence of many poets in the oral tradition does not necessarily mean that many poets wrote the final Iliad and Odyssey.

A 2021 article in Cambridge’s Journal of Classics Teaching makes precisely this distinction, arguing for a long history of oral composition but largely individual authorship of the surviving epics. That is one scholarly position, not a universally accepted conclusion. Cambridge University Press +2

For a broader understanding of the debate, Harvard’s Center for Hellenic Studies, particularly the work of Gregory Nagy, is worth exploring. Nagy takes an especially interesting approach to the evolution of Homeric poetry through oral tradition. The Center for Hellenic Studies +2

5. Why this matters for Emerson

I think this is the most interesting part of your passage from Richardson.

Consider what Emerson was encountering around 1820.

He was being introduced to a new intellectual possibility:

  • Ancient literature was not necessarily the product of isolated geniuses.

  • Great poetry could emerge from collective cultural experience.

  • The poet might be the embodiment of a tradition rather than simply its inventor.

  • Religious and literary texts could have complicated histories of development and transmission.

There is a potentially important connection here to Emerson’s later understanding of the poet.

Emerson increasingly regarded the poet as someone who gives expression to something larger than his individual personality: the accumulated experience, imagination and spiritual life of humanity.

That doesn’t mean Wolf’s Homeric theory directly produced Emerson’s mature philosophy. But it helps explain why Everett’s teaching could have been so intellectually stimulating.

There is another interesting connection: the books mentioned in your passage, particularly Robert Lowth’s Lectures on the Sacred Poetry of the Hebrews and Thomas Blackwell’s An Enquiry into the Life and Writings of Homer.

Robert Lowth

Examined the literary structure, parallelism and poetic character of Hebrew scripture.

Thomas Blackwell

Examined Homer as a product of his historical, geographical and cultural environment.

These writers were questioning the relationship between the individual poet, the culture that produced him, and the character of sacred or classical literature.

That is a fascinating intellectual environment for a young Emerson.

6. A reading recommendation

If you want to follow this particular intellectual thread, I would suggest three works:

  • Blackwell’s An Enquiry into the Life and Writings of Homer (1735) — particularly relevant to what Emerson was reading.

  • Wolf’s Prolegomena ad Homerum (1795) — the foundational challenge to conventional Homeric authorship.

  • The Singer of Tales by Albert Lord (1960) — probably the most illuminating book for understanding what oral composition actually means.

My larger takeaway: Everett introduced Emerson to something more consequential than a controversial theory about Homer. He introduced him to historical and critical ways of thinking about the origins of human wisdom and literature.

And that is a very promising place to look for the beginnings of Emerson’s intellectual independence.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Your Elephant has dreamed of India

This is a fascinating passage because Rumi is doing two things at once: bringing a story about generosity and the relinquishing of wealth to a conclusion, and then showing us what happens when someone

 
 
 
Get into the bath

The key to understanding Rumi’s image in Masnavi, Book IV, verses 238–242, is to recognize that the bathhouse is not simply a place to wash. It is a metaphor for spiritual purification, and the furnac

 
 
 
Who is the pbuh?

PBUH stands for “Peace Be Upon Him.” It is an expression of respect and blessing used by Muslims whenever they mention the Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم). In Arabic, the expression is: Sallalla

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by Nick Martinez. Proudly created with Wix.com

© Copyright
bottom of page