top of page

How to read Diogenes Laertius

Writer: davidsmith208
davidsmith208
Nov 12
5 min read

This is a particularly interesting passage because it gives us a glimpse of how the ancient Greeks understood Egyptian intellectual traditions—and, more importantly, how much of what we call Greek philosophy may have originated in, or been influenced by, older Egyptian and Near Eastern thought.

The author is Diogenes Laërtius, one of the most valuable sources for the history of ancient philosophy.

1. Who was Diogenes Laërtius?

Diogenes Laërtius

Probably lived in the first half of the third century CE (approximately 200–250 CE).

We know remarkably little about his personal life. He was a Greek biographer and compiler of philosophical history, rather than a philosopher who established his own school.

His principal work is called Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers.

It consists of ten books and preserves biographies, teachings, anecdotes, quotations, letters, and philosophical doctrines from many earlier thinkers.

It is especially valuable because many of the original works he discusses have disappeared.

In effect, he is a window into a much larger library of ancient philosophy that we would otherwise have lost.

2. Why is he interesting to read?

There are several reasons.

  • He preserves lost traditions. He quotes or summarizes philosophers whose original writings no longer survive.

  • He records competing schools. Platonists, Aristotelians, Stoics, Epicureans, Cynics, and others.

  • He records intellectual lineages. Who taught whom, who influenced whom, and how philosophical traditions developed.

  • He includes unusual personal details. His biographies contain anecdotes, sayings, controversies, and sometimes quite entertaining stories.

  • He preserves ancient accounts of other civilizations. Your Egyptian passage is a good example.

One qualification: Diogenes is a compiler, writing centuries after many of the people he describes. His accounts are not always historically reliable. He sometimes repeats conflicting traditions without resolving them.

Nevertheless, he is indispensable for studying ancient philosophy.

3. Does the Egyptian passage suggest that the Earth goes around the Sun?

This is where I would be careful. The passage contains some surprisingly sophisticated astronomical knowledge, but it does not establish a heliocentric solar system.

Let’s separate its claims.

A spherical universe

They reportedly believed the universe was spherical. This is an important cosmological idea, although it doesn’t tell us whether the Earth moves.

A scientific explanation of lunar eclipses

They understood that the Earth casts a shadow onto the Moon. This is genuine astronomical knowledge. It is consistent with the ancient Greek geocentric model, in which the Earth is stationary at the center.

Stars made of fire

They believed stars were fiery bodies and that their composition or mixture influenced terrestrial events. This combines physical speculation with astrology.

Astronomy and arithmetic

They claimed to have developed geometry, astronomy, and arithmetic. Egypt had a substantial mathematical and astronomical tradition, particularly connected with calendars, agriculture, and timekeeping.

Interestingly, the idea that the Earth revolves around the Sun was proposed in ancient Greece by Aristarchus of Samos in the third century BCE.

But Diogenes’ description does not attribute that idea to the Egyptians.

4. What about reincarnation?

This is perhaps the most interesting philosophical aspect of your passage.

The text says:

The soul survives death and passes into other bodies.

That is a recognizable doctrine of transmigration of souls, often called metempsychosis.

It is associated with several ancient traditions:

  • Egyptian religion: The soul’s continued existence after death and its transformation or journey through different states were central themes. However, Egyptian beliefs about the afterlife were not necessarily identical to reincarnation.

  • Pythagoras: The Pythagorean tradition held that the soul could pass from one living body to another.

  • Plato: In dialogues such as Phaedo and Republic, Plato discusses the soul’s immortality and successive lives.

  • Indian philosophy: Rebirth and the cycle of existence, samsara, became central concepts in Hindu, Buddhist, and Jain traditions.

There is an important distinction here: surviving death is not the same as being reborn in another body.

Diogenes explicitly attributes both ideas to the Egyptian tradition.

I find this particularly worth investigating because it raises a fascinating historical question: did Greek philosophers develop these ideas independently, inherit them from Egyptian traditions, or encounter related ideas through multiple cultural exchanges?

We cannot confidently settle that question from this passage alone.

5. Who were Hecataeus and Aristagoras?

These names are important because they take us closer to the original sources behind Diogenes.

Hecataeus of Abdera (c. 360–290 BCE)

Hecataeus of Abdera

A Greek historian and philosophical writer who lived during the time of Alexander the Great and the early Ptolemaic dynasty in Egypt.

He is particularly interesting because he actually visited Egypt, during the reign of Ptolemy I.

He wrote a work about Egyptian civilization, usually called Aegyptiaca, which discussed:

  • Egyptian religion and mythology.

  • Egyptian political institutions and laws.

  • The antiquity of Egyptian civilization.

  • Egyptian customs and philosophical ideas.

His writings have largely disappeared, but fragments survive through later authors, including Diodorus Siculus and Diogenes Laërtius. OUP Academic +1

Aristagoras

This is more difficult.

Diogenes mentions Aristagoras alongside Hecataeus as an authority on Egyptian physical explanations of nature.

However, Aristagoras is not securely identifiable from this reference. We cannot confidently establish his biography, which particular Aristagoras he was, or the precise work Diogenes had in mind.

I would not assume that he was the better-known Aristagoras of Miletus, who was involved in the Ionian Revolt against Persia around 500 BCE.

Manetho — another person worth knowing

Manetho

An Egyptian priest and historian who lived in the third century BCE, under the Ptolemaic rulers.

Manetho wrote a history of Egypt, called Aegyptiaca, organizing Egyptian rulers into dynasties.

He also wrote about Egyptian religious and natural philosophy. His Epitome of Physical Doctrines, cited in your passage, survives only through references and fragments.

Manetho is particularly significant because he was an Egyptian writing about his own civilization in the Greek-speaking intellectual world. Manetho’s Sacred Book +1

6. Something especially interesting about the passage

I would draw your attention to the opening of Diogenes’ entire work, immediately before the passage you quoted.

He raises a controversy:

Did philosophy originate with the Greeks, or did it originate among older civilizations?

He mentions:

  • The Persian Magi.

  • Babylonian and Assyrian Chaldeans.

  • Indian Gymnosophists (ascetics).

  • Celtic and Gallic Druids.

  • Egyptian priests and prophets.

Some authorities argued that philosophy began among these older civilizations. Others insisted that philosophy was exclusively Greek.

Diogenes himself ultimately sides with the Greek-origin argument, but he preserves the alternative accounts. Perseus Digital Library +1

This makes Book I particularly worthwhile for someone interested in comparative philosophy.

There is a fascinating historical tension here: the Greeks developed a remarkable tradition of rational inquiry, but they were also heirs to civilizations that had accumulated mathematical, astronomical, medical, religious, and cosmological knowledge for thousands of years.

My recommendation: Don’t skip Book I. Read it slowly, especially its opening discussion of the origins of philosophy. It provides a useful framework for thinking about the relationship between Egyptian, Indian, Persian, and Greek thought.

One further connection might interest you: Diogenes’ discussion of Pythagoras later in the book (Book VIII) addresses his travels and associations with Egyptian and other foreign traditions. That is worth comparing with the Egyptian doctrine of transmigration of souls discussed here. OUP Academic +1

You can read the complete work here:

The question I would keep in mind while reading is this: Are we reading the actual philosophy of ancient Egypt, or a Greek interpretation of Egyptian philosophy? That distinction is crucial, and it is one of the most interesting problems in the history of philosophy.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Your Elephant has dreamed of India

This is a fascinating passage because Rumi is doing two things at once: bringing a story about generosity and the relinquishing of wealth to a conclusion, and then showing us what happens when someone

 
 
 
Get into the bath

The key to understanding Rumi’s image in Masnavi, Book IV, verses 238–242, is to recognize that the bathhouse is not simply a place to wash. It is a metaphor for spiritual purification, and the furnac

 
 
 
Who is the pbuh?

PBUH stands for “Peace Be Upon Him.” It is an expression of respect and blessing used by Muslims whenever they mention the Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم). In Arabic, the expression is: Sallalla

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by Nick Martinez. Proudly created with Wix.com

© Copyright
bottom of page