top of page

Quiet Sitting

Writer: davidsmith208
davidsmith208
5 days ago
7 min read

The passage is describing an important aspect of Neo-Confucian spiritual practice: the belief that a person can recover direct awareness of their original moral nature through disciplined stillness.

The two Chinese terms are particularly revealing because they connect a practical discipline (quiet sitting) with a philosophical understanding of human nature.

Let’s distinguish the words first, then look at what the practitioners actually did.

1. Jingzuo (靜坐) — quiet sitting

Pinyin: jìngzuò · Traditional Chinese: 靜坐 · Simplified: 静坐

The two characters mean:

  • Jing (靜): quiet, stillness, tranquility, freedom from disturbance.

  • Zuo (坐): to sit.

Literally, then, sitting in stillness.

But it meant considerably more than simply sitting quietly. It was a deliberate exercise in disciplining attention, settling the mind, and becoming receptive to one’s underlying nature.

It is important not to assume that this was simply Buddhist meditation under a Confucian name. Although Neo-Confucians were influenced by Buddhist and Daoist contemplative traditions, they developed their own philosophical understanding of the practice.

Their central question was not merely how to escape thought or achieve an unusual state of consciousness. It was how to become aware of the moral principle already inherent in human nature.

2. Benxing (本性) — original or inherent nature

Pinyin: běnxìng · Traditional Chinese: 本性

  • Ben (本): root, origin, foundation, that which is fundamental.

  • Xing (性): nature, innate disposition, essential character.

The term is often translated as original nature, inherent nature, or one’s fundamental nature.

Here we encounter an important idea in Chinese philosophy, particularly the thought of Mencius (Mengzi).

Mencius argued that human beings are innately good. We possess the beginnings of moral qualities that can be cultivated into full virtue.

He identified four fundamental moral inclinations:

  • Compassion — the beginning of benevolence (ren 仁).

  • Shame and aversion to wrongdoing — the beginning of righteousness (yi 義).

  • Deference and courtesy — the beginning of propriety (li 禮).

  • The ability to distinguish right from wrong — the beginning of wisdom (zhi 智).

These are not virtues that have to be imported into us from outside. They are already present, although they may be undeveloped, obscured, or neglected.

This is the philosophical foundation of the meditation Mabuchi is describing.

The practitioner is not trying to manufacture a new personality. He is trying to recover something fundamental that is already there.

There is an interesting distinction in Neo-Confucianism between:

  • Benxing (本性): original or inherent nature, understood in its moral perfection.

  • Qizhi zhi xing (氣質之性): nature as expressed through one’s particular physical and psychological constitution, shaped by one’s qi (vital energy).

In the Cheng brothers’ and Zhu Xi’s philosophical framework, the quality of one’s qi can obscure the expression of one’s inherent moral nature.

Quiet sitting was one proposed means of settling the mind and allowing that underlying moral nature to become apparent. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy +2

3. What did they actually do when they sat?

This is where the history becomes especially interesting.

There was no single standardized Confucian meditation technique. Practices varied considerably, and some were much closer to Buddhist or Daoist meditation than others.

Mabuchi identifies several techniques used in Confucian meditation manuals:

  • Regulating the breath.

  • Circulating qi through the body.

  • Concentrating attention on the dantian (丹田), the lower abdominal energy center.

  • Maintaining complete silence.

  • Sitting in the lotus position.

These techniques show that Confucian scholars were not isolated from the contemplative traditions around them. They borrowed, adapted, and sometimes argued against Buddhist and Daoist methods. DOI +1

But one particular seventeenth-century Confucian scholar gives us an unusually detailed account of what quiet sitting could mean in practice.

4. Gao Panlong (高攀龍, 1562–1626): the seven-day practice

Gao Panlong

A major late-Ming Confucian scholar associated with the Donglin intellectual movement. He was deeply committed to moral cultivation and developed a particularly interesting system of quiet sitting.

Gao wrote a text called Fu Qi Gui (復七規), approximately translated as Rules for Returning in Seven Days.

He took the seven-day idea from the I Ching (Book of Changes), specifically the hexagram Fu (復), usually translated as Return or Returning.

The symbolism is significant: after the cycle of decline, the original movement of life returns.

Gao applied this idea to the restoration of the human mind and spirit.

His instructions are remarkably concrete.

The seven-day practice

Gao wrote that when one becomes fatigued through engagement with the world, one should withdraw into stillness for seven days to restore the body, clarify the mind, and strengthen one’s original vitality.

His instructions include:

1. Preparation: Spend the preceding day relaxing the body and mind. Sleep when tired and remove accumulated fatigue.

2. Entering stillness: Enter the room, burn incense, and sit cross-legged.

3. Awakening the mind: The essential instruction is to awaken the mind so that it remains clear, alert, and luminous.

4. No particular objective: Do not direct the mind toward a particular destination. Do not become attached to a location or anticipated result.

5. Avoid forcing concentration: Do not struggle to suppress thoughts. Maintain a clear, attentive state.

6. After three days: Gao says that one should reach a particularly profound state.

7. Days four through seven: Maintain vigilance against laziness and mental dullness. Walk gently after meals, avoid excessive food and meat, and sleep only when necessary.

By the seventh day, he expected the practitioner to experience renewed vitality and mental clarity.

This is not merely an abstract philosophical proposition. Gao was prescribing an actual retreat. PDF +2

Gao’s most revealing instruction

In his other text, Jingzuo Shuo (靜坐說), or On Quiet Sitting, Gao gives a more philosophical explanation.

One of his instructions reads:

靜坐之法,喚醒此心,卓然常明,志無所適而已。

A translation would be:

The method of quiet sitting is to awaken this mind, keeping it upright, clear, and constantly luminous, with no particular direction toward which the will is set.

He goes on to explain something particularly important:

  • Do not forcibly eliminate wandering thoughts.

  • Do not try to manufacture a special psychological experience.

  • Do not become attached to the results of meditation.

  • Allow the original clarity of the mind to reveal itself.

He describes the original nature as something ordinarily present but obscured by disturbances.

One particularly striking passage says that when the true nature becomes manifest, wandering thoughts naturally subside.

He also makes a point that is essential to understanding his philosophy:

Stillness and activity should ultimately become one.

The purpose of sitting quietly is not to remain withdrawn from the world. What is discovered in stillness must also be present when one returns to ordinary activity.

His ideal is a person whose mind remains clear and morally grounded whether sitting alone, reading, working, or interacting with others. Xuges +1

5. Why was there a danger in quiet sitting?

This brings us back to the last sentence of your excerpt, which ends with:

“There was an inherent danger in the psychological transformation produced by quiet sitting…”

Mabuchi’s abstract identifies the central problem.

If someone discovers an extraordinary state of tranquility, they might begin to believe that stillness itself is the highest achievement.

Several difficulties follow:

  • Withdrawal: The practitioner might become less interested in social and moral responsibilities.

  • Attachment to experience: The pleasurable experience of mental emptiness might become an end in itself.

  • Buddhist influence: Confucians worried that quiet sitting could lead toward Buddhist conceptions of emptiness, detachment, or the rejection of ordinary worldly concerns.

  • Neglect of learning and conduct: A person might believe that inner experience alone provides sufficient wisdom, without the study of the Confucian classics or the cultivation of moral behavior.

This was a genuine disagreement within Neo-Confucianism.

For example, Zhu Xi accepted quiet sitting as a useful aid to mental discipline, but resisted the idea that one could directly perceive one’s moral nature simply by becoming tranquil.

He emphasized that moral understanding must also be developed through study, reflection, and engagement with the world.

Gao Panlong, meanwhile, tried to formulate a practice in which stillness and moral awareness reinforced one another rather than becoming separate pursuits. plato.stanford.edu +2

6. A connection worth exploring: Confucianism, Daoism, and your earlier reading

I think there is a particularly interesting philosophical comparison here.

Consider three approaches:

Tradition

Central contemplative concern

Daoism

Returning to the natural, unforced condition of the Way

Buddhism

Understanding the nature of mind and overcoming attachment

Neo-Confucianism

Recovering and expressing one’s inherent moral nature

There are similarities in the methods, but important differences in their philosophical objectives.

For instance, Gao’s instruction not to force the elimination of thoughts resembles certain Daoist and Chan Buddhist approaches.

Yet he interprets the resulting clarity through Confucian ideas of ren (仁), benevolence, li (理), principle, and xing (性), nature.

His concern is ultimately ethical: how does one become a person whose spontaneous responses embody goodness?

Three primary texts worth pursuing

1. Gao Panlong — Gaozi Yishu (高子遺書)

His collected writings. Look particularly for Fu Qi Gui (復七規), Jingzuo Shuo (靜坐說), and Shan Ju Kecheng (山居課程).

Primary source · Late Ming

2. Mencius

Particularly Book 2A, where Mencius discusses the four beginnings of moral nature and the cultivation of the mind.

Foundational philosophical source

3. Masaya Mabuchi — “Quiet Sitting in Neo-Confucianism”

Chapter 11 of Asian Traditions of Meditation, pages 207–226 (2016).

Modern scholarly study

My central observation: Gao Panlong’s conception of quiet sitting is not an attempt to empty the mind of its contents, nor simply to achieve relaxation. It is an attempt to become sufficiently still that the mind’s original clarity and moral character can be experienced without interference.

That raises a fascinating question: Is the goodness of human nature something we discover through introspection, or something that becomes evident only when we live and act in the world?

That tension is at the heart of Neo-Confucian meditation.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Your Elephant has dreamed of India

This is a fascinating passage because Rumi is doing two things at once: bringing a story about generosity and the relinquishing of wealth to a conclusion, and then showing us what happens when someone

 
 
 
Get into the bath

The key to understanding Rumi’s image in Masnavi, Book IV, verses 238–242, is to recognize that the bathhouse is not simply a place to wash. It is a metaphor for spiritual purification, and the furnac

 
 
 
Who is the pbuh?

PBUH stands for “Peace Be Upon Him.” It is an expression of respect and blessing used by Muslims whenever they mention the Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم). In Arabic, the expression is: Sallalla

 
 
 

Comments


© 2023 by Nick Martinez. Proudly created with Wix.com

© Copyright
bottom of page