Reconstructing the mysteries
There is a fascinating problem with Édouard Schuré’s Pythagoras and the Delphic Mysteries: it is partly a history of ancient Greek philosophy, partly a reconstruction of an ancient mystery school, and partly a work of spiritual philosophy.
I would read it with interest, but also with some historical caution. Schuré is trying to recover something he believes was the inner spiritual teaching behind Pythagoras, rather than simply describe what historians can establish about him.
Let’s look at his sources and then at the three figures you mention: Lysis, Hierocles, and Philolaus.
1. Where does Schuré get his information?
Édouard Schuré (1841–1929)
French writer and spiritual philosopher. His book was originally published in French in 1889 as Les Grands Initiés (The Great Initiates). The English translation of the Pythagoras section appeared as Pythagoras and the Delphic Mysteries.
Schuré drew on several different kinds of material:
Ancient biographical accounts: Diogenes Laertius, Porphyry and Iamblichus, who wrote about Pythagoras and his followers centuries after Pythagoras lived.
Plato: Particularly the Phaedo, Timaeus and other dialogues containing references to Pythagorean ideas.
Greek philosophical traditions: Later Neoplatonic writers, including Hierocles.
Nineteenth-century scholarship: The historical and philosophical interpretations available to European writers of his period.
His own spiritual reconstruction: His account of the initiation stages, the inner teachings, and the dramatic details of Pythagoras’ life are not all supported by surviving ancient evidence.
The important distinction is that Pythagoras himself left no known writings. The detailed biographies we have were written roughly 700–800 years after his lifetime. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy +1
Schuré’s book is therefore not a transcription of an ancient secret teaching. It is his attempt to reconstruct one.
One particularly important passage is in Schuré’s first chapter. He actually tells us what he regards as the surviving foundations of Pythagorean teaching:
The Golden Verses of Lysis
The commentary of Hierocles
Fragments of Philolaus
Plato’s Timaeus
That is a very revealing list. Schuré is combining four quite different kinds of evidence. Project Gutenberg
2. Who was Lysis?
Lysis of Thebes was a Pythagorean philosopher who lived during the fifth and early fourth centuries BCE.
He is particularly interesting because he is associated with Epaminondas (c. 418–362 BCE), one of the great Theban generals.
According to the ancient tradition:
Lysis escaped the persecution of the Pythagoreans in southern Italy.
He eventually settled in Thebes.
He became the teacher of Epaminondas.
Epaminondas reportedly regarded him almost as a father.
Aristoxenus, a fourth-century BCE philosopher and music theorist with connections to the Pythagorean tradition, is an important source for this story. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy +1
What are the Golden Verses?
These are a collection of approximately 71 short moral and spiritual instructions attributed to Pythagoras.
They begin with instructions concerning reverence toward the gods, parents and family, and proceed toward self-examination, mastery of the passions, purification and the ultimate destiny of the soul.
Here is an example of their central spirit:
Never allow sleep to close your eyes after going to bed until you have examined all your actions of the day.
This is an ancient practice of daily self-examination, remarkably similar to certain Stoic and contemplative disciplines.
An important qualification: although Schuré calls them the Golden Verses of Lysis, we cannot establish that Lysis actually wrote them. They are an anonymous work of the Pythagorean tradition, probably composed much later than Lysis.
There is also a Platonic dialogue called Lysis, but that is a different matter. It is a dialogue about friendship, featuring a young Athenian boy named Lysis. It is not a biography of the Pythagorean philosopher.
3. Who was Hierocles?
Hierocles of Alexandria
Approximately fifth century CE.
Notice the dates: he lived nearly 1,000 years after Pythagoras.
This is an especially important distinction.
Hierocles was a Neoplatonic philosopher who wrote a substantial commentary on the Pythagorean Golden Verses.
His commentary survives and is one of the most interesting documents for understanding how later Greek philosophers interpreted Pythagorean ethics and spirituality.
His central ideas include:
Philosophy as purification of the soul.
The cultivation of virtue as preparation for divine likeness.
The relationship between the human soul and the divine order.
The importance of self-knowledge and moral discipline.
The soul’s restoration to its proper spiritual condition.
Hierocles interpreted the Golden Verses as an integrated philosophical system, not merely a collection of moral sayings.
His commentary is particularly valuable because it shows how Pythagorean philosophy was understood within later Platonism. It does not, however, give us direct access to what Pythagoras himself taught.
A modern scholarly study worth knowing is Hermann S. Schibli’s Hierocles of Alexandria (2002), which includes an English translation of the commentary. OUP Academic +1
4. Philolaus — probably the most important of the three
Philolaus of Croton
Approximately 470–385 BCE.
Contemporary with Socrates, and one of the earliest Pythagorean philosophers whose actual writings have survived in fragments.
I think Philolaus is the figure you should pay particular attention to if you want to get behind Schuré’s spiritual interpretation and encounter the actual philosophical thinking of the early Pythagoreans.
Unlike Pythagoras, Philolaus apparently wrote a book, traditionally called On Nature.
He developed a remarkable cosmology based on three fundamental ideas:
1. Limiters and unlimiteds
The universe consists of two kinds of principles:
Unlimiteds: things without inherent measure or structure.
Limiters: principles that give things measure, form and definition.
2. Harmony
The universe becomes intelligible through the harmonious fitting together of these two principles.
3. Number
Number provides the means by which we understand the structure and relationships of things.
This is not merely the proposition that mathematics is useful for describing the universe. It is the much more profound idea that the intelligible order of the universe depends upon mathematical relationships.
What fragments of Philolaus actually survive?
This is where the scholarship becomes particularly interesting.
The ancient collection of his supposed writings contains more than twenty fragments, but modern scholars generally accept approximately eleven as authentic.
The fragments are conventionally numbered DK 44 B1–B6, B6a, B7, B13, B16 and B17. Some details of authenticity remain debated. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy +1
Here are some particularly interesting ones:
Fragment 1 — The nature of the universe
Nature in the world-order was fitted together out of things which are unlimited and out of things which are limiting.
This is the foundation of his philosophy.
Fragment 2 — The necessity of both principles
Philolaus argues that the fundamental elements of reality cannot consist entirely of unlimited things. There must also be limiting principles.
Otherwise, there could be no definite objects or intelligible order.
Fragment 6 — Harmony
He argues that things which are unlike and unrelated require harmony if they are to be brought together into an ordered whole.
This is perhaps the most philosophically interesting aspect of his system.
Harmony is not simply something beautiful that happens to exist in the universe. It is a principle that makes the universe possible.
Fragment 6a — Musical ratios
Here Philolaus explains the mathematical relationships underlying musical intervals.
The Pythagorean musical relationships
Octave
2 : 1
A doubling of frequency
Fifth
3 : 2
The relationship between two notes separated by a fifth
Fourth
4 : 3
The relationship between two notes separated by a fourth
These relationships are important because they demonstrate how apparently different things can be brought into a unified mathematical order.
Philolaus sees the same principle operating throughout the cosmos.
Fragment 7 — The central fire
He describes the first thing fitted together in the cosmos as the hearth at its center.
This belongs to his unusual astronomical model, in which Earth is not at the center of the universe. Earth revolves around a central fire, along with the other heavenly bodies.
It is a remarkable departure from the conventional geocentric picture.
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy +2
Where can you read these fragments?
I recommend Carl Huffman’s scholarly work, Philolaus of Croton: Pythagorean and Presocratic (1993).
Also consult the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy entry:
It is particularly useful because it distinguishes authentic fragments from later writings falsely attributed to Philolaus.
5. What about Plato?
Plato (c. 427–347 BCE)
Plato is important because he is one of our earliest substantial literary witnesses to Pythagorean thought.
Three dialogues are particularly relevant:
Dialogue
Why it matters
Phaedo
Mentions Philolaus and explores the soul, death and immortality.
Timaeus
Presents a mathematical and harmonious construction of the cosmos.
Philebus
Explores the relationship between limit and unlimitedness.
The Timaeus is especially interesting in relation to Philolaus.
Plato constructs an account of the universe in which mathematical proportions and harmony are fundamental to cosmic order.
There are substantial similarities to Philolaus, although Plato develops his own philosophical system.
An ancient tradition even claimed that Plato obtained writings from Philolaus. But the details of that story are uncertain, and the suggestion that Plato simply copied Philolaus is not accepted by modern scholarship. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy +1
6. My interpretation of what Schuré is attempting
I think the most interesting way to approach this book is to recognize that Schuré is trying to connect three different levels of human understanding:
The ethical level
Lysis and the Golden Verses
How should a person live? How does one discipline the passions, examine oneself and purify the soul?
The philosophical level
Philolaus and Plato
What is the underlying order of the universe? What is the relationship between number, harmony, matter and spirit?
The contemplative level
Hierocles and the mystery tradition
How does the human soul transform itself and recover its relationship with the divine?
This is the architecture of Schuré’s interpretation.
One caution: his descriptions of secret initiations, detailed stages of spiritual advancement and the transmission of ancient wisdom from Egypt and India are not established historical facts. They belong substantially to his own nineteenth-century esoteric interpretation.
7. What I would read next
Given your interest in the I Ching, Lao-tse, and the philosophical rather than fortune-telling side of ancient traditions, I think these would be particularly rewarding:
The Golden Verses of Pythagoras — read them slowly, as a practical philosophy of daily self-examination.
Philolaus: Fragments — to encounter the actual surviving early Pythagorean philosophy.
Plato’s Timaeus — to explore the relationship between mathematical harmony and the structure of the universe.
Hierocles’ Commentary on the Golden Verses — to see how a later philosopher interpreted the spiritual purpose of the Pythagorean way of life.
One final thought: there is a striking difference between the historical evidence for Pythagoras and the spiritual tradition that developed around him. The historical evidence is fragmentary, but the tradition is extraordinarily rich.
It is worth keeping those two things separate without necessarily dismissing either.

Comments